+191
Carrie Underwood was definitely the best American Idol winner, amirite?
by Anonymous13 years ago
And the hottest :D
by Anonymous13 years ago
Personally, I like Kelly Clarkson more (though she's fading away now). I think Carrie Underwood will stay around the longest.
by Anonymous13 years ago
for me its a tie between Kelly Clarkson and Carrie. cant decide.
by Anonymous13 years ago
chris allen was terrible. he should NOT have won.
by Anonymous13 years ago
At least he's straight.
by Anonymous13 years ago
so...? Just because somebody's gay, doesn't mean that they can't be a great singer?
by Anonymous13 years ago
i agree. adam lambert was far more talented.
by Anonymous13 years ago
Taylor Hicks all the way!!!
I hope everyone caught my sarcasm there...
by Anonymous13 years ago
Kelly Clarkson♥
The only song I like from Carrie Underwood is Ever After. :P
by Anonymous13 years ago
Chris Daughtry was the best
by Anonymous13 years ago
He didn't win.
by Anonymous13 years ago
woops I thought he won. guess not. but i still like him better than carrie underwood
by Anonymous13 years ago
Yeah, he was very talented. But he didn't want to win. He's more successful than he would have been if he won.
by Anonymous13 years ago
Ruben won, Clay Aiken came in second, I'm pretty sure
by Anonymous13 years ago
That was the 2nd season. Chris came later on. Haha
by Anonymous13 years ago
Wow I'm going crazy, I could've sworn that said Clay haha
by Anonymous13 years ago
I like Kelly Clarkson most (not really anymore, but her first two albums), but Carrie's a close second. I don't even like most country music yet I like her, haha.
by Anonymous13 years ago
hmm, maybe. i dunno... i liked chris daughtry too.
by Anonymous13 years ago
I'd have to go with my boy Ruben Studdard.
by Anonymous13 years ago
Carrie Underwood was on CANADAIAN idol...
by Anonymous13 years ago
Actually she was the Season 4 winner of American Idol. She's not even from Canada.
by Anonymous13 years ago
1. You're wrong. 2. *Canadian.
by Anonymous13 years ago
How about runner ups xP Clay Aiken was way better than Carie Underwood (Pure Sarcasm) I agree that Adam Lambert was way better than Kris Allen.
by Anonymous13 years ago
kris allen was the best, by far
by Anonymous13 years ago
....sarcasm?
by Anonymous13 years ago
nope:)
by Anonymous13 years ago
I pity you.
by Anonymous13 years ago
Um... who hasn't been mentioned yet...
Fantasia?
by Anonymous13 years ago
I feel William Hung and the general should be mentioned in this conversation as well
by Anonymous13 years ago
WILLIAM HUNG. <3
by Anonymous13 years ago
winners? yes. all other people? ADAM LAMBERT.
by Anonymous13 years ago
Kelly Clarkson was the best vocalist, next to Fantasia, but Carrie's got the looks and fanbase to stick around longest.
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago
by Anonymous 13 years ago