Opened peanut butter belongs in the fridge, not the cabinet/cupboard, amirite?

I keep it in the cupboard, there's nothing wrong with it. It seems to me that cold peanut butter would taste bad, not to mention be hard to spread.

You monster

Why would one do such a horrid thing?

Yes for organic, not needed for non-organic.

seahorses...foreva

Oh you!

Only if it's organic peanut butter. Which is kind of a crime itself...