Well if a guy looks normal and doesn't come up to you in a creepy way I wouldn't find it creepy :)
Not true. I broke into her window in all black and everything romantically and she still called the cops.
If he's your boyfriend or a good friend it's one thing... If he's some random dude on the street it's another. It also depends on what he looks like and how he approaches.
It shouldn't matter what he looks like just take the compliment.
Not if he looks like a creeper. My creep radar wins out over my ego.
Meh, didn't mean it that way. I didn't mean it like you think I meant it, I meant it like if he looks creepy, it's just going to be creepy. Shoulda been clearer, sorry.
I think it's a little creepy if you barely know them.
Some guys say it all the time so it just loses it's meaning.
I have a ton of friends like that. It's like SERIOUSLY, JUST TAKE THE DAMN COMPLIMENT. not every girl has someone come up to her and call her beautiful -__-