-479

Instead of genre, music should be sorted by what it's about. For example, instead of pop, country, rock, metal, alternative, etc., it should be: Love, boyfriends, girlfriends, ex-boyfriends, ex-girlfriends, one night stands, crushes, family, friends, life, alcohol, etc., amirite?

22%Yeah You Are78%No Way
Irish_Wolffs avatar Music
Share
8 29
The voters have decided that Irish_Wolff is wrong! Vote on the post to say if you agree or disagree.

There would be a rather large genre of "this band was on drugs and nobody knows what this song is supposed to mean"

_pi_s avatar _pi_ No Way +46Reply

what about classical music which isn't necessarily about anything.

Saigots avatar Saigot No Way +40Reply

It's funny cuz the average Taylor Swift song would fit into at least three of those categories.

But different songs can be interpreted in different ways

plus, just because you like one song about a certain category doens't mean you'll another song in the same category, ie rap girlfriend song vs. country girlfriend song.

idiot.

Anonymous +10Reply

...Why?

D_Sexys avatar D_Sexy No Way +9Reply

What about instrumental songs D:

You are dumb. Fo real.

Anonymous +8Reply

I agreed until I saw everyone else's comments about why this wouldn't make sense. :P

people don't necessarily listen to music because of the lyrics. The sound (aka THE GENRE) is what usually interest them first.

Anonymous +7Reply

Most songs would be soooo hard to categorize!

YYA'ing this because it's so wut it's lol.

Alexuss avatar Alexus Yeah You Are +5Reply

These catergories listed all sound terrible.

That would get a lot of 8 year olds in trouble and no one would have a fave genre then

Anonymous +4Reply

make your own fucking playlists. This is a terrible suggestion for most people.

Anonymous +4Reply

On its own this would be a bad idea, but if you sub-categorized it might work. Ex: Pop-Love, or Rap-Girlfriend... not saying I think this should happen, just that this would be a better idea.

Anonymous +2Reply

Most of the time you can't detect the actual purpose of the song. Only the artist will know the true meaning and sometimes they might not want to give that away.

Anonymous +2Reply

Okay, one question: the song Freshmen by Verve Pipe. It was about the guy's girlfriend getting an abortion in highschool. what category would THAT go into?

lol, this is actually the STUPIDEST idea i have ever heard, amirite?

Anonymous -3Reply
Please   login   or signup   to leave a comment.