+133

It's kinda unfair that Michael Phelps is considered like a god, because there is no other sport that you can win 8+ medals an Olympics, he is an unbelievable/the best swimmer ever, but there is no other sport that you can win that many medals to potentially get more medals than him, amirite?

82%Yeah You Are18%No Way
flandlewagons avatar People & Celebrities
Share
1 30
The voters have decided that flandlewagon is right! Vote on the post to say if you agree or disagree.

I think someone could be a multi track star or gymnast...

@Skr3wBall I think someone could be a multi track star or gymnast...

The lady who's record he beat for the most gold Olympic medals was a gymnast.

SpearmintMilks avatar SpearmintMilk Yeah You Are +15Reply
@Skr3wBall I think someone could be a multi track star or gymnast...

Anyone who wins in sprinting is not going to specialize in long distance. So that's not even an option.

Anonymous +10Reply
@Skr3wBall I think someone could be a multi track star or gymnast...

Yeah, in theory, couldn't you also do 100, 200, 400, 800, 1500, 5000 and 10,000, and then also the relays? I'm not saying there's anyone that can or would, but you could in theory. And yes, i think gymnastics might be the only other realistic option - all round individual, all round team, and then as many of the inidividual apparatus as you can!

@Skr3wBall I think someone could be a multi track star or gymnast...

Well, sort of. A sprinter develops different muscles than a long distance runner. They also learn to converse their energy differently and breathe differently. It's hard to imagine someone being gold-medal material in both types of events. I doubt someone with the leaner long-distance muscles would excel in sprinting. Both are great athletes, but they are different.

Anonymous +8Reply
@Skr3wBall I think someone could be a multi track star or gymnast...

this is why i added "in theory" - there's no REAL reason why it couldn't happen. No truly scientific reason I mean.

@Skr3wBall I think someone could be a multi track star or gymnast...

Doesn't make it impossible though, that's the point. Swimmers also usually specialize in one stroke - so it's even more amazing that Phelps is so good at more than one.

Just the fact that he's versatile enough to be dominant at all those different events over and over makes him a god. He's probably one of the most consistent Olympians too, so he's the greatest whether he has the most medals or not.

@GiggityGoo22 Just the fact that he's versatile enough to be dominant at all those different events over and over makes him a...

Yes, plus "greatest olympian" remains a rather subjective thing anyway. I mean, how do you really measure it? Steve Redgrave is the only one who's won gold in 5 consecutive olympics. Does that make HIM the greatest? Is pure number of golds the real defining factor? How about people who have NEVER used doping? I mean, there are dozens of possible criteria to use. I agree that Phelps deserves his place in the hall of fame, but I'm wary of using terms like single greatest olympian of all time.

@GiggityGoo22 Just the fact that he's versatile enough to be dominant at all those different events over and over makes him a...

If you have multiple golds and world records, there's not really a problem with identifying someone as the best or most skilled.

@GiggityGoo22 Just the fact that he's versatile enough to be dominant at all those different events over and over makes him a...

sure you could try that, but the same problems exist. Do you measure it on pure number of golds? number of olympics? number of records? their sportsmanship? It's hard to be truly objective about it

@GiggityGoo22 Just the fact that he's versatile enough to be dominant at all those different events over and over makes him a...

But we're not identifying them as "the best", the title in question is "Greatest Olympian"

@GiggityGoo22 Just the fact that he's versatile enough to be dominant at all those different events over and over makes him a...

I really don't see what's so wrong with letting him be the greatest Olympian. He's awesome just let him have it.

@GiggityGoo22 Just the fact that he's versatile enough to be dominant at all those different events over and over makes him a...

You did notice that I disagreed with the OP right? that I think it is perfectly fair to think of Phelps as a "god"? But the objective title of "greatest olympian of all time" is a bit of a fallacy. I don't think there should be this title. As it was suggested before, more specific titles are fitting. This general title has too many criteria

@GiggityGoo22 Just the fact that he's versatile enough to be dominant at all those different events over and over makes him a...

Oh, i see, you just like it when people shut up and agree with you? Well, I don't agree with you, and I'm telling you thus.

@GiggityGoo22 Just the fact that he's versatile enough to be dominant at all those different events over and over makes him a...

Okay you're telling me thus that's great, but this isn't a debate tournament. This is kind of a waste of time.

This user has deactivated their account.
@1782866

For the record, it totally does

@1782866

Not really.

Anonymous -11Reply

Of the previous Top 10 Men, and Top 10 Women for the most medals, none of the olympians have been swimmers.
http://www.olympic.org/Document...nter_Games.pdf

I learned to swim at the same place michael phelps trained. Just a fun fact

Anonymous +1Reply

Teddy Rinner (judo gold) has won 5 world judo competions 3 Europe ones and an olympi gold. They aren't all Olympic medals but they're just as important, if not more within that sport

Please   login   or signup   to leave a comment.