+26

Freedom of Speech gives you the right to offend others, amirite?

85%Yeah You Are15%No Way
PhilboydStudges avatar Politics
Share
3 23
The voters have decided that PhilboydStudge is right! Vote on the post to say if you agree or disagree.
This comment was deleted by its author.
@2040023

People are certainly free to criticize and think what they will. Would you agree, though, that the consequences one faces should not include acts of lawlessness? For example, should the consequences of drawing Mohammed include death threats and perhaps even violence?

PhilboydStudges avatar PhilboydStudge Yeah You Are 0Reply
This comment was deleted by its author.
@2040057

Many people would have answered my question differently. That's why I asked.

PhilboydStudges avatar PhilboydStudge Yeah You Are +1Reply

Sure, you can use your free speech to be offensive. Others can use their speech to challenge it. And some will go further than merely challenging an offensive remark, they will take action to disassociate themselves from offensive characters... this too is their right.

ForkNdaRoads avatar ForkNdaRoad Yeah You Are +4Reply
This user has been banned.
@2039954

Absolutely.

PhilboydStudges avatar PhilboydStudge Yeah You Are 0Reply

What it does not give you the right to do is harm them with lies, assassinating their character. Inciting a riot is also outside of it's scope. Offending someone? Within the boundaries.

@JerryHendrickson What it does not give you the right to do is harm them with lies, assassinating their character. Inciting a riot...

Yes. The obligatory example is yelling 'fire' in a theater. That ones obvious to me. The difficultly, at least for me, is defining the boundaries. Satire often ridicules people. Celebrities and politicians routinely have their characters assassinated with halve truths and falsehoods. It can be aggravating, but I believe still needs to be protected.

PhilboydStudges avatar PhilboydStudge Yeah You Are +2Reply
@PhilboydStudge Yes. The obligatory example is yelling 'fire' in a theater. That ones obvious to me. The difficultly, at least...

Any sort of character assassination should have to prove true; otherwise, it's unlawful and Unconstitutional. Freedom and liberty should always lie within the boundaries of not harming innocent others.

@JerryHendrickson Any sort of character assassination should have to prove true; otherwise, it's unlawful and Unconstitutional...

You might find this interesting. It's an excerpt from this page (http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyc...ple-29718.html). I make no claims for its accuracy, but it seems reasonable.

Defamation law tries to balance competing interests: On the one hand, people should not ruin others' lives by telling lies about them; but on the other hand, people should be able to speak freely without fear of litigation over every insult, disagreement, or mistake. Political and social disagreement is important in a free society, and we obviously don't all share the same opinions or beliefs. For instance, political opponents often reach opposite conclusions from the same facts, and editorial cartoonists often exaggerate facts to make their point.

PhilboydStudges avatar PhilboydStudge Yeah You Are 0Reply

Technically, yes, it does....with some exceptions it means we can say whatever we wish. But, with every right comes an equal responsibility - and these days we seem to forget that responsibility for ourselves. We are responsible to not be complete and utter jerks and say things i such a way that we KNOW we are being offensive.

SugarSkulls avatar SugarSkull Yeah You Are +2Reply
This comment was deleted by its author.
@2039924

I don't understand your comment. To me it sounds as if you agree with the OP.

PhilboydStudges avatar PhilboydStudge Yeah You Are +1Reply
This comment was deleted by its author.
@2039976

Would you be willing to expound your position?

PhilboydStudges avatar PhilboydStudge Yeah You Are 0Reply
This comment was deleted by its author.
@2039983

It seems reasonable then to conclude your position is baseless.

PhilboydStudges avatar PhilboydStudge Yeah You Are +2Reply
This user has deactivated their account.
@2040142

Thank you.

PhilboydStudges avatar PhilboydStudge Yeah You Are 0Reply

freedomwins

Cezars avatar Cezar Yeah You Are +1Reply

Technically freedom of speech gives you the right to criticize the government without fear of arrest. Our strange social norms give you the "right" to offend others.

Anonymous