Freddy Krueger must have pricked himself with his glove when trying to scratch an itch on more than one occasion. amirite?

So Mr Pirate how did you lose the eye?

I was scratching my eye.

How did scratching your eye make you lose it?

It twas the day after I got the hook.

Hence the terrible skin.

Not itching without nerve endings my guy

Ball itch, ftl

Well, burns do itch